Showing posts with label Mark Kermode. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mark Kermode. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 December 2009

“What was the effect of the DPP list?” presentation script!

“What was the effect of the DPP list?”

By Oliver Hunt

Introduction

‘What was the effect of the DPP list?’ The DPP list is a list made by the BBFC and consisted of seventy four films which in the late seventies and early eighties where deemed too dangerous to be shown across the UK. Several films where added and taken off at one point or another and the list was first made public in June 1983.

It is unclear where the term Video Nasty came from however most people believe it first started in a British newspaper.

Some of the most popular and well known are Sam Raimi’s The Evil Dead [Item 2] and Wes Craven’s Last House on the Left [Item 1] however other slightly well know films such as Cannibal Holocaust, are well known between horror fans.

Video Nasties that never made the DPP list

There also where some films on the DPP list which where never caught up in the ‘Video Nasty’ scare.

The more notable films where The Exorcist and The Texas Chain Saw Massacre. I believe that because The Exorcist was nominated for ten Academy Awards in 1973 it was not counted as a ‘Video Nasties’ because they had a reputation for being low-budget horror and with The Texas Chain Saw Massacre it’s hard to speculate. [Item 20]

Both however have been released on DVD uncut in the past decade almost thirty years after their release.

Who are the BBFC?

The BBFC are the British Board of Film Certification and have been running since 1912 as an “Independent body to bring a degree of uniformity to the classification of film”.

The BBFC classify every film that comes into the UK. A film needs a certificate by the BBFC otherwise it can not be distributed legally.

The Obscene Publications Act, 1959 and 1964

Then the Obscene Publications Act, 1959 and 1964 (OPA) made it illegal to publish any work which is obscene. In the late seventies early eighties, if a video managed to ‘deprave and corrupt’ an audience then it is deemed obscene. [Item 14]

For a film to ‘deprave and corrupt’ an audience it means that a film must be morally bad. For a film to be uncertificated by the BBFC because of the OPA, the film must be taken as a whole and not to be judged based on one or two scenes. [Item 16]

My focus Nasties

For my study on what the effect of the DPP list was, I looked at three well known video nasties. Wes Craven’s The Last House on the Left, Sam Raimi’s The Evil Dead and Meir Zachi‘s I Spit on Your Grave. Each film, like so many other video nasties have only recently been released on DVD and uncut DVD’s in the UK.

Controversially behind The Last House on the Left

The Last House on the Left has had the most coverage because of persistent fans wanting the film to be released uncut. The film was first rejected for a certificate by the BBFC in July 1974 because of it’s extreme images of rape and murder.

In 2000 the film was represented to the BBFC but was turned down once again. Then in 2002 the distributors: Blue Underground Limited, made an appeal with the Video Appeals Committee so they could get the BBFC to give the film a certificate. They lost in the appeal because the BBFC wanted them to cut a total of sixteen seconds of sexual and violent images so the film could receive an 18 certificate which they weren’t prepared to do. So they brought in film critic Mark Kermode (who I will be mentioning through out because of his knowledge of video nasties) as a horror expert to produce a report on the films historical importance. After the BBFC read the report they changed the cuts from sixteen seconds up to thirty one. [Item 13, Item 20]

The cuts where made and the film was given the 18 certificate allowing it to be released. In July 2002, twenty eight years after it was first rejected, the film was finally released on DVD. It wasn’t until March 2008 when the film was first released uncut by the BBFC.

Controversially behind the other Nasties

With The Evil Dead and I Spit on your Grave the story of their releases where less complicated.

For The Evil Dead the BBFC insisted on cutting a long list of things. One scene involved a pencil being stabbed into a young woman’s ankle and twisted which the BBFC had cut down. [SHOW CLIP – THE EVIL DEAD - PENCIL SCENE] [Item 12]

With The Evil Dead the board of the BBFC at the time where split on whether the film was ‘over the top’ or ‘nauseating’. I think that The Evil Dead is a prime example that most (if not all) ‘Video Nasties’ are over the top. [Item 18]

For I Spit of your Grave the BBFC wanted to cut seven minutes of rape scenes watch became just 41 seconds of the heroine being raped over a rock. [Item 12]

Was the BBFC biased against The Last House on the Left?

In an article with Sight & Sound magazine, Mark Kermode argued that maybe the BBFC where more strict on English speaking films and The Last House on the Left in particular. He stated that with foreign films such a Saló and Baise-moi which involved more scenes that could ‘deprave and corrupt’ it’s audiences, but they where given a certificate by the BBFC. Because of this many people believe that the BBFC where biased against Last House on the Left. This isn’t hard to believe because of the amount of times the film got rejected. [Item 15]

Is there any point of a remake?

This year The Last House on the Left was remade by director Dennis Iliadis who is fresh into the business and with Wes Craven as the producer. This isn’t surprising seeing how he also produced the remake of his second film The Hills Have Eyes back in 2006. [SHOW CLIPS - The Last House on the Left (1972) - Trailer and The Last House on the Left (2009) - OFFICIAL TV SPOT 1]

The 1974 original was really a test on how far the horror genre and cinema can be taken. The film was made in response to the images coming out of Vietnam and Wes Craven himself walked out of the Reservoir Dogs premiere because he said it was just violence for entertainment but after this remake of one of cinema’s grittiest films, it seems like either he’s gone back on his words or is cashing in. [Item 11, Item 13]

I think that the remake doesn’t have any meaning or themes behind it (even if Dennis Iliadis has some war experiences). The original film is even a remake of a 1960 Swedish film called Virgin Springs.

I feel that this film was made for nothing more then for money. The original was banned because of it extreme nature and this remake is trying to ride on the films reputation.

In the Empire Magazine review for the remake; Kim Newson commented that original horror remakes are necessary but I think that simply can’t be the case with The Last House on the Left because the film was so horrible and grotesque that it shouldn’t be repeated. [Item 11]

Did the Video Nasties have an effect?

Now on too what was the effect of ‘Video Nasties’ on society. If films that where banned under the Obscene Publication’s Act where banned because they would ‘corrupt & deprave’ audiences then it must have some effect on it’s audiences? [Item 6]

In 1998 two months before the Columbine High School Massacre there was another high school shootings. According to newspapers the two teenage killers where addicted to ‘pizza and Video Nasties’ and that it was in fact the Video Nasties which led them to kill five people. [Item 9]

However this wouldn’t be the first time in the past decade that Video Nasties could have corrupted young minds. A few years back and a little closer to home; the James Bulger killing was reported in mainly newspapers to have ‘Chilling Connections’ between the murder act and the movie Child’s Play 3 (which was called a Video Nasty even though it was released in 1991). It was said that the killers mimicked what they saw in the film. [Item 4]

This leads to what Karen Newson said in her report; THE NEWSON REPORT: A case study in ‘common sense’. She said that maybe the killers from the High School massacre and even James Bulger’s child killers, emotionally connected to not the protagonist but the antagonist, in this case Chucky. [Item 4]

But is the DPP list something to point blame at? What about the families they came from? Or what their mental state was at the time? And how about the music they where listening to? I think it’s unfair to say that films on the DPP list are manufacturing killers. I even think that it’s not the fault of the movies because thousands of horror fans and non-horror fans watch ‘Video Nasties’ and do not go out a kill people. I believe it is their mental state which had ‘depraved & corrupted’ them from regular social behaviour.

Modern Video Nasties

After researching why some of the films where banned I began to look at films that would today be branded ‘Video Nasties’.

The first films I’m going to mention is David Cronenberg’s Crash which came out in 1996. When the film came out it was badly received and banned because of it’s controversial subject matter and was argued in a British newspaper, that is was morally bad.

More films which people will recognise are the Saw and Hostel franchises, which feel a lot like ‘Video Nasties’ and possible even Se7en.

The film I feel is most like a Video Nasty and likely to ‘deprave & corrupt’ is Lars von Trier’s Antichrist which has been released uncut in the UK. [Item 17]

In a video blog, Mark Kermode commented on what a newspaper said about Antichrist, the newspaper said: “Antichrist ticks off every box for it to be obscene with real sex scenes and genital mutilation and should be seen as morally repugnant.”

What his argument was, was that a film shouldn’t be judged as obscene because of what it does to it’s audiences but what it did to the production team.

I agree with his statement because how can the BBFC say what effect it will have on audiences. He even mentioned that Antichrist and The Evil Dead are similar in that they “both are set in a cabin in the woods, they are both about evil and they are both spam in a cabin horror movies” which also is a fair comment.

Conclusion

So to sum up everything and what I feel the effect of the DPP list was. I believe that a lot of the films from the DPP where graphic and disturbing, which possible led troubled and unsafe minds to commit murderous acts. However I believe it wasn’t just cinema alone which ‘depraves & corrupted’ them. I think that it was their own sanity which did it and films from the DPP list where an easy target for newspapers to point blame at. I also agree with Mark Kermode’s statement that a film shouldn’t be judged on a whether it will ‘deprave & corrupt’ audiences but if it had any effect on the production team. I Think the BBFC can’t say what effect art will have on it’s audiences. [Item 13]

I think that remakes of classic Video Nasties are only being produced because of the controversy and popularity that surrounds them whilst also believing that stories about rape, murdered and other gruesome acts shouldn’t constitute for a remake.

Really modern horror cinema has been formed out of the films from the DDP list. Films like Saw might not have come about if films like Driller Killer hadn’t be made or shocked audiences and modem horror films have a lot to thank for those films which where demeaned to ‘deprave & corrupt’ audiences. [Item 19]

Oliver Hunt

Thursday, 1 October 2009

I Was a Teenage Horror Fan...

I found a great article about what The Evil Dead meant to fans. And as Mark Kermode has said in the past; there is a fine line between us and them when it comes to horror (the ‘us’ being horror fans, myself included and the ‘them’ being everyone else). But what this also does is sort of justify what die hard fans see in video nasties (the majority and of course ruling out rape revenge films) and why we keep seeing more and more of these low budget films.

Item: I Was a Teenage Horror Fan or, ‘How I learned to stop worrying and love Linda Blair’ by Mark Kermode (age 36) – (Ill Effects: The Media/Violence debate – Second edition, edited Martin Barker and Julian Petley, 2001, page 131-132)

“The truth is simply that the experience horror fan understands the on-screen action in terms of a heritage of genre knowledge which absolutely precludes the possibility of sadistic titillation. Nowhere in The Evil Dead does the horror fan see the actual torture, mutilation or violence of the human form (as they would do in a John McNaughton’s solidly unfunny Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer). What they see is the playful trashing of a tradition of special effects work, in which the refining of various latex additives has opened up vistas of possibilities for enthusiastic armature film-makers everywhere. To the horroe fans, The Evil Dead is about as threatening as a pop group smashing up their guitars on stage – it’s stupid, but it’s huge fun none the less.”

Tuesday, 15 September 2009

Sight & Sound Article 'Left On The Shelf'

Mark Kermode questions the BBFC's 'new openness'

This is an interesting article from Sight & Sound which as the title states, involves Mark Kermode questioning the BBFC on their ‘new openess’. He talks about other film like Romance, Ai no corrida, Saló and Baise-moi and how there subject matter was delt by the BBFC in comparison to Last House on the Left. All those foreign films dealt with rape scene in what seems like a harsher way (e.g. real penetration) whilst in Last House- the scene where cut because the Krug & Company where wielding knifes at the two girls and cut them.
So what Mark Kermode was trying to get at was; is the BBFC biased against not only English speaking films but more importantly the Last House on the Left?


Also I’d like to point out I do use a lot of Mark Kermode’s work because he seems to know a lot about the film and it’s history and was very important in it’s release in the UK.

Sunday, 13 September 2009

Last House On The Left censorship info

'Last House on the Left uncut DVD release' Mark Kermode Uncut Blog

This is a nice introduction to the whole controversy which gave The Last House on the Left it’s bad reputation in the UK. It’s a Uncut Blog from Mark Kermode’s BBC page. I couldn’t get the video from the page so here’s the link.
Because of the film’s cult success, the film was once again presented to have a certificate by the BBFC. It was British movie critics such as Mark Kermode stated that Wes Craven’s gory and messy debut film was an important piece of work and should be allowed to be seen by die hard horror fans. He’s even said that Last House on the Left should be in the collection of any true horror buff and if it’s cut then it’s no good, all or nothing.Back in 2000 the film was presented again to the BBFC to finally get a certificate so the film could be distributed to the horror fans. It had been nearly thirty ears since the films release and was banned everywhere through the 80’s and 90’s. The filmed was denied (BBFC report 11th February 2000) by the BBFC however there was a one off showing of the film in Leicester in June of the same year.Two years later in the same month it was shown in Leicester. The film was shown uncut along with Texas Chain Saw Massacre which was also also uncut (I believe) and it was Blue Underground, a DVD distributor of Video Nasties and exploitation films, which got the films shown. Last House on the Left could be shown uncut at a cinema screening because the BBFC do not have jurisdiction when it comes to cinema showings, thus the films where shown. Because of the success the film screening had, Blue Underground built up the confident to once again try and get the film distributed uncut.

When brought to The BBFC for the second time they won against the Video Appeals Committee*. The BBFC wanted just 16 seconds of the film to be cut for it to receive a 18 certificated. They even brought in Mark Kermode as an expert in the horror genre to write up a report about the films importance. When the BBFC looked through the report they doubled the 16 seconds worth of cuts to 31 seconds. The film was finally released thirty one years (May 2003) after the films release (BBFC report 17th July 02) with an obvious 18 certificate. On the DVD the cut scenes were viewable as a slideshow extra on the disc, and there was a weblink to a website where the cut scenes could be viewed. So even though they where cut from the film the fans could still view them. It wasn’t untill March 17th 2008 that the film finally got released uncut (BBFC report March 17th 08) by the BBFC and since then different cuts where released of the film including the rare alternative cut called ‘Krug and Company’.

*The Video Appeals Committee was set up by the Video Recordings Act and was made because if any film or video game (‘Manhunt’ for example) is refused by the BBFC then it can be appealed to VAC which has the power to order the BBFC to reverse its decision and to grant a certificate to the disputed work.

Monday, 7 September 2009

Censorship of the Movies + The Evil Dead Censorship Info

In this section I’ll be showing and talking about the scenes from each movie which where censored and why I thought they might have been cut out. Also I am adding other information on why the films where put on the DPP list and then became video nasties.

Evil Dead
Cut Scene – The scene where Linda is stabbed in the ankle but the then possessed Deadite Cheryl.



Why I think it was cut out
Personally I don’t think this should have be cut out because the blood doesn’t look believable thus it not so much ruins the illusion that this girl has been stabbed but that the film was made by early twenty something’s out to make a quick fright. Now the tree rape scene on the other hand is very disturbing in that it could have been avoided. But it begs the question; did Sam Raimi keep that scene in so people would talk and discuss rape in (at the time) modern cinema. With films like I Spit On Your Grave
and more ironically Last House on the Left, showing rape scenes it coursed controversy with the media and lead to the films being edited down or even not distributed (which film makes obviously don’t want). But also films out side the horror genre scenes of rape where put in, for example Straw Dogs which was released the same year as A Clockwork Orange both involved rape and murder. Were film-makers bringing to attention the state of society in the 70’s and earily 80’s by showing rape as entertainment? Was the tree rape scene in Evil Dead put in to reflect those realistic rape scenes with an over the top one and make a sick joke out of it?


Info on Censorship
Because of its graphic violence, the original version of the movie was banned in several countries, including Finland, Germany, Iceland and Ireland. The "tree rape" scene in the movie was also described by some as being misogynistic. In Germany, the movie’s release was hindered by public authorities for almost 10 years. Original 1982 cinema and video releases of the movie had been seized, making the movie successful on the black market video circuit with pirated copies abounding. Several well-known horror enthusiasts publicly criticized the German ban on the movie, including author Stephen King (who gave it a rave review in the November 1982 issue of Twilight Zone). A heavily edited version was made available legally during 1992. During 2001 an uncut German DVD version was released, but the Berlin-Tiergarten Court ordered seizure of the DVD in April 2002 (Case Number 351 Gs 1749/02). In Finland, The Evil Dead was later released uncut on DVD by Future Film, and rated K-18. In the United Kingdom, the movie was one of the first to be abelled a video nasty during the mid-1980s and was finally released uncut in 2001.
-Wikipedia


Next blog 'DPP the List' then 'Last House on the Left Censorship Info' up soon…


[UPDATE] Mark Kermode on the Evil Dead cuts
Back in June 08, Mark Kermode released an Uncut Video Blog which detailed some on the cuts the BBFC watch Sam Raimi to do with his gore-com the Evil Dead. And In fact he didn’t mention the tree rape scene but he did mention the stabbing in ankle bit and specified that it wasn’t the stabbing they wanted band but how the Deadite twists the pencil. He also mentioned that’s the BBFC watch the bit where Shelly chews off her own hand (when she is holding the knife) to be reduced which he then went on to mocked. But to summaries he had the list of things the BBFC wanted Raimi to cut from the film so it could get a rating.

Source - Kermode Uncut Blog - With Gruesome Pleasure


Now this has interested me to find the hole list of what the BBFC wanted to cut from the Evil Dead and indeed Last House- and Cannibal Apocalypse. I’m going to do some searching and try find the lists which I will then post up here.