Showing posts with label Media And Violence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Media And Violence. Show all posts

Tuesday, 22 September 2009

Newson’s Report on Violence in films and it’s effect on the viewer

This section is from the book ‘Media And Violence’ by Karen Boyle. I’m adding it to my blog because it’s interesting what happened years ago when Childs Play 3 came out and how the Jame Bulger killing was (could have been) connected to the movie. This was interesting to me because even though it’s talking about Robert Thompson (one of James Bulger’s killer) could have identified with Chucky. I felt that the same terms could be true with Last House on the Left or even the protagonist in I Spit on Your Grave.

“Newson suggest that in films like Child’s Play 3 the viewer identifies with the perpetrator of violence – an interesting claim in light of the tabloid confusion over the ‘chilling links’ between original and copy and one that contradicts much of the research on identification processes. Nevertheless, the report received extensive media coverage, dissenting voices where barely heard and the pressure on the Conservative government to ‘do something’ increased. For those who accepted the link between the murder of James Bulger and Child’s Play 3, the ‘something’ to be done was in many ways obvious: these videos must be censored, contained and controlled. In this context of panic and misinformation, and amendment to the Video Recording Act was passed, stipulating that in awarding certificates to films on video, the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) must consider the potential for harming to viewers (and to underage viewers in particular) watching in the home”
The Effects of Violence in the Media - page 5

Do Video Nasties cause High School shootings?

This is taken from the book ‘Media And Violence’ by Karen Boyle. It talks about how the killers of a high school killing prior to Columbine where fans of Video Nasties. However I feel that it wasn’t the video nasties that did it. The media also say that they where fans of video game and other violent mediums. But it’s still a good section.

“I want to turn to a report in The Sun a few months prior to the Columbine massacre. Sensationally Headlined ‘BOYS KILL FIVE THEN EAT PIZZA’ (2 December, 1998), the report described how two teenage boys, ‘massacred five people for kicks after watching video nasties’. Whilst the article goes on to suggest a causal link between ‘video nasties’ and murder, no one would seriously suggest that there is a casual link between murder and pizza eating. Rather, the juxtaposition of murder and pizza eating is supposed to tell us something on the killers (their lack of remorse, callousness and so on). Yet, on the basis of the evidence offered, the ‘murder causes pizza eating’ hypothesis is as plausible as the ‘viewing video nasties cause murder’ hypothesis. All we are told is that one event followed the other, just like killing followed bowling in the Columbine case. However, we are so used to video nasties being linked to murder that this lack of evidence is not glaringly obvious.”
The Effects of Violence in the Media Page 5-6